top of page
Color White top.png

ESG, a Broken Car, and Two Very Intelligent Opponents

6 days ago
13 min read

I agreed with my opponents. Then I defended ESG anyway. And somehow, we all ended up winning.


After an intense debate about ESG, we decided to settle our differences the old-fashioned way. Fortunately, it was all smiles, and no punches were thrown.


Have you ever found yourself passionately defending something you don't entirely believe in?


Well, that is precisely what happened to me at the CC Forum "Investment in Sustainable Development" in London two weeks ago.


And to make matters worse, I had to defend it against two rather intelligent gentlemen whose arguments I largely agreed with!


The subject?

“ESG: A Force for Good or a Tool of Economic and Geopolitical Control?”


Now, after more than 30 years working in sustainability, finance and Impact Investing, I have developed quite a few opinions about ESG. And I must confess, not all of them are particularly flattering.


I have seen the greenwashing, the absurd ratings, the endless paperwork and the extraordinary ability of some corporations to look wonderfully sustainable on paper while doing rather questionable things in the real world.


In fact, when my old friend Max S., President of CC Forum, invited me to defend ESG, my first reaction was to laugh.


Max, are you sure you have the right person?


Because, you see, I was originally much closer to the position of my opponents!


And these were no ordinary opponents.


On one side were Terrence keelay (Terry), former Managing Director at BlackRock and now Chairman and CEO of Impact Evaluation Lab, and Simon Littlewood, Chairman of LI Family Office and CEO of SDG Global Group.


Both highly experienced, sharp thinkers, and certainly not gentlemen who would be easily persuaded by a few beautiful speeches about saving the planet.


On my side was Mike Beaver, a London-based finance professional and CFA charterholder, and together we had the rather entertaining task of defending a system whose shortcomings we could hardly deny.


So there I was, preparing to argue against two gentlemen who were about to say many of the things I had been saying myself for years.


How on earth was I supposed to win that debate?


Fortunately, I had one advantage.


I knew their arguments. I understood their frustrations. And, most importantly, I realized that while we agreed on much of what was wrong with ESG, we disagreed on something far more fundamental.


Does a broken system deserve to be abandoned, or does it deserve to be repaired?


And that reminded me of something rather familiar to any parent.


A teenager who has just dented the family car.


Little did I know that this poor imaginary teenager would end up stealing the show, making the audience laugh and helping bring a rather heated subject to an unexpectedly friendly conclusion.


But I am getting ahead of myself.

Let me tell you what happened.


The uncomfortable truth about ESG


I knew Terry's arguments reasonably well. In fact, having spent more than 30 years in sustainability and Impact Investing, I could already predict most of the criticisms he was going to raise.


I even told him so at the beginning of the debate!

And rather wonderfully, Terry agreed with me.

Actually, something unexpected happened during our exchanges. Twice, Terry came to my defence, openly saying that he agreed with the points I was making.


Now, that is not something you necessarily expect when facing a highly intelligent opponent in a public debate!


I began to wonder whether I was becoming better at arguing or whether Terry was gradually joining our side.


Unfortunately, he did not go quite that far!


But it demonstrated something important. Our disagreement was not really about the failures of ESG. We both recognized many of those failures.


The real disagreement was about what we should do next.

ESG ratings have become a rather strange business.

How can companies responsible for enormous pollution, such as Exxon or BP, sometimes receive favorable ESG ratings? How can businesses selling harmful products, or corporations with questionable labor practices, sometimes score better than companies genuinely trying to make the world a better place?

The explanation, of course, is that many ESG ratings measure how environmental, social and governance issues affect a company's financial risks rather than the actual impact the company has on society.

But isn't that exactly part of the problem?

And what about the small businesses that cannot afford armies of consultants, lawyers and sustainability experts to fill in endless forms?

We have created a system in which a company can sometimes spend more money demonstrating how responsible it is than actually becoming responsible!

There is something rather absurd about that.

Add greenwashing, inconsistent rating methodologies, questionable accountability and the growing geopolitical influence of sustainability standards, and you begin to wonder whether ESG has lost its way.

So, when Terry and Simon made their arguments, I could hardly disagree with much of what they were saying.

Which created a small problem.

How do you win a debate when you agree with your opponents?

Fortunately, after spending more than three decades in sustainability and finance, I have learnt that agreeing with someone does not necessarily mean arriving at the same conclusion.

And that was precisely where our differences began.

ESG is like a teenager who has dented the family car

I began by telling the audience that defending ESG today is rather like defending a teenager who has just dented the family car.

They mean well. They are growing. But they certainly have some explaining to do!

That brought some welcome laughter.

And I suspect quite a few parents in the audience knew exactly what I was talking about.

But behind the humour was a serious point.

A flawed instrument is not necessarily a useless instrument.

When your teenage son damages the car, you don't immediately conclude that cars are a terrible invention and that humanity should return to horses.

You repair the car, perhaps have a serious conversation with your son, and hopefully make sure he drives more carefully next time.

Why should we treat ESG any differently?

And that brings me to the five arguments I put forward in its defence.

1. ESG is the foundation. Impact is the roof.

One of the central arguments against ESG is that we should move beyond ESG ratings and focus on genuine, measurable impact.

Wonderful!

Nobody could be happier about that than me.

I have spent much of my professional life developing and promoting Impact Investing, long before it became fashionable.

But there is one little problem.


How do you measure impact without information?


ESG, despite all its weaknesses, helped introduce sustainability into the language of mainstream finance.

It pushed major corporations to disclose information about environmental risks, social practices and corporate governance.

It brought subjects once dismissed as moral considerations into boardrooms, investment committees and discussions about financial performance.

Of course, disclosure is not the same as impact.

A beautiful sustainability report does not clean a polluted river.

And a five-star ESG rating does not necessarily make a company a responsible corporate citizen.

But without reliable information, measuring and demanding genuine impact becomes considerably harder.

ESG is not the destination. It is part of the road that makes the destination reachable.

And this brings me to something else.


2. Sometimes you change the world by staying at the table

There is a widespread belief that responsible investors should simply sell their shares in companies they consider harmful.

But think about it.

If responsible investors sell their shares in Exxon, who buys them?

Perhaps someone who cares even less about climate change.

And what exactly have we achieved?

The company continues operating, while those who might have influenced its behavior have walked away.

Sometimes engagement, shareholder voting and persistent pressure on management can achieve more than simply excluding a company from an investment portfolio.


You don't necessarily change a company by selling its shares. You can also change it by remaining at the table and demanding better.


And I have seen how much attitudes towards sustainability in mainstream finance have changed.

I recalled a dinner many years ago when Terry's former colleague Larry at BlackRock told me that he was considering incorporating sustainability into annual reporting.

I nearly spilled red wine all over my white shirt!

Fortunately, I no longer have that problem.

I stopped drinking wine.

But jokes aside, I remember those days very well.

There was a time when discussing sustainability with mainstream financial institutions was almost embarrassing.

And that is something we should not forget.


3. We must stop making sustainability an elitist club

Here Simon's criticism deserves particular attention.

If ESG becomes a system where only large corporations can afford compliance, while smaller businesses and companies in emerging economies are disadvantaged, then something has gone seriously wrong.

Sustainability should not become a privilege of the wealthy.

Nor should international standards become instruments through which powerful economies dictate the development paths of poorer nations.

Smaller businesses cannot afford armies of consultants to prepare complicated sustainability reports.

But the answer cannot be to eliminate accountability altogether.


The answer is to make ESG practical, affordable and proportionate.


At Impact Investing Solutions (IIS), we are already seeing efforts to develop simpler sustainability standards for smaller businesses and private companies.


I also believe the growing attention to double materiality is an important step forward.

It asks not only how environmental and social developments affect a company's finances, but also how the company's own activities affect people and the planet.

That second question is absolutely fundamental.


Because surely the purpose of sustainability cannot be merely to protect corporate profits from environmental damage while ignoring the damage those corporations may be causing themselves.


We need genuine accountability in both directions.

And that brings us closer to the real-world outcomes that Impact Investing and the Sustainable Development Goals seek to achieve.


4. ESG made sustainability speak able in mainstream finance

More than 15 years ago, at a banking forum in Zurich, an economics professor told me directly:

“Sustainability and impact are morality, not economics.”

Imagine that.

Today such a statement might sound rather outdated. But I remember very well how difficult it was to bring these subjects into mainstream financial discussions.


For decades, people like my old friend Dr. Ashok Khosla, former President of Club of Rome worked tirelessly to bring sustainable development into mainstream economic thinking.


Another old friend, former US Vice President Al Gore, helped demonstrate that sustainability could also become part of a serious investment strategy.


Believe me, in those days even Wall Street did not always take such ideas seriously.

Today, climate risks, resource efficiency, social responsibility and governance are regular subjects in financial discussions.


ESG did not create these concerns.

But it helped translate them into a language that the financial world could understand.

And that transformation matters enormously.

We fought for decades to convince financial institutions that environmental and social issues were not merely matters of morality, but also fundamental to economic prosperity and long-term financial stability.

I would be rather reluctant to throw away that progress.


5. Correct the system instead of allowing it to become a tool of control

Terry and Simon were right to raise concerns about ESG becoming an instrument of economic and geopolitical influence.

This is not an imaginary danger.


When powerful institutions define sustainability standards without sufficient transparency, proportionality or consideration of local circumstances, those standards can become a way of imposing economic and political priorities on others.

And the consequences can be particularly serious for developing economies and smaller businesses.


But surely the answer is not to abandon responsibility.

It is to ensure that the institutions setting the standards are themselves responsible and accountable.


The European Union has taken steps to regulate ESG rating providers, seeking greater transparency, integrity and accountability.


Whether every regulation is well designed is another question entirely.

I certainly don't believe that producing more regulations automatically produces a better world.


Sometimes it simply produces more consultants!

But the important point is that weaknesses in the system are being recognised and addressed.


If ESG is to serve society, it must itself be subject to transparency, scrutiny and accountability.


Otherwise, a framework intended to promote responsibility can become precisely the tool of economic and political influence that its critics fear.


And that is why I believe reform is so important.


The question nobody answered

As the debate progressed, I found myself increasingly amused by something.

Terry and Simon were doing an excellent job explaining everything that was wrong with ESG.

And I agreed with much of it.


Terry even came to my defence twice during the debate, acknowledging that he agreed with the points I was making.


So perhaps we were not quite as far apart as the audience might initially have thought.

But there was one question that kept bothering me.


If we abolish ESG, what exactly are we going to replace it with?


I asked that question once.

No clear answer.

So, later in the debate, I asked it again.


And once again, the question remained unanswered.


Now, I am not suggesting that Terry and Simon did not have ideas about how sustainable finance should evolve.


Quite the contrary.

Terry has written extensively about moving beyond ESG towards genuine Impact Investing, an ambition I very much share.


But that still leaves an important practical question.

What replaces the transparency, disclosure and accountability mechanisms that ESG has helped introduce into mainstream finance?

What framework would allow investors to assess corporate environmental and social performance in a consistent and meaningful way?

And how do we ensure that, in dismantling a flawed system, we do not also dismantle the progress it has made possible?

For me, this was the central unresolved question of the debate.


It is relatively easy to demonstrate that a system is broken. It is much harder to explain what should replace it and how we get there.


And unless we can answer that question convincingly, abandoning ESG risks creating a vacuum rather than progress.


That was why, in my closing statement, I thanked Terry and Simon for their excellent arguments and said:

“They have shown us why ESG needs to change. They have not shown us why it needs to disappear.”


I then asked the audience something very simple.

When a company pollutes a river, exploits its workers or destroys a forest, do we really want investors to know less about it?


When powerful corporations influence governments and societies, do we want less transparency, less accountability and less responsibility?


Surely not.

We have fought for decades to make the financial world understand that the future of our planet and the future of our economy are not two separate things.


Are we now going to abandon that progress simply because the framework we created is imperfect?


Impact without measurement is a promise. And measurement without accountability is just paperwork.


We need both.

A broken car, a good laugh and an unexpected result

As I approached the end, I returned to our poor teenager and the damaged family car.

I told my opponents:

“You have convinced us that the car needs repairing. But you still haven't convinced me why we should stop driving towards a better future!”


The audience laughed and applauded.

I suspect the broken-car analogy resonated more than some of my carefully prepared financial arguments.


Perhaps I should remember that for my next debate!

And then something rather lovely happened.


Despite our differences, the debate ended in a very friendly and constructive spirit.


Both sides were declared winners.


Now, some might suggest that declaring everyone a winner is a rather diplomatic way of avoiding a difficult decision.


But I actually thought it was a fitting conclusion.

Because perhaps neither side was entirely wrong.

Terry and Simon were right to challenge ESG's contradictions, its shortcomings and the danger of sustainability becoming another instrument of power.

Mike and I were right to argue that abandoning ESG without something better to replace it would risk losing decades of hard-won progress.

And perhaps, somewhere between these positions, lies a much more useful future for sustainable finance.


From opponents to friends — and a book to keep us arguing

There was, however, another rather special aspect of the debate which I enjoyed enormously.


As I mentioned earlier, Terry actually came to my defence twice, openly agreeing with points I was making.


Considering that we were supposed to be on opposing sides, I found that rather refreshing.

It also confirmed something I have believed for a long time:

Intelligent people do not have to disagree about everything simply because they find themselves on opposite sides of a debate.


And somewhere in the middle of our lively exchanges, I noticed something else.

Terry had started referring to me as “my friend.”

Now, I am not entirely sure whether I had managed to convince him of anything, or whether he had simply decided that I was not quite as unreasonable as he had initially feared!

But I rather liked that.


Because isn't that exactly what a good debate should achieve?

We can challenge each other's arguments, disagree strongly on important issues, and still discover that we have far more in common than we initially thought.

And the friendly spirit continued after the debate.


Terry and I even posed for a rather funny picture together, with our fellow debaters joining in the fun.


Looking at title picture above, you might think we had just finished a boxing match rather than an intellectual debate about sustainable finance.


Fortunately, nobody was injured, and I don't believe anyone demanded a rematch!

Terry also very kindly gifted me a copy of his book, Sustainable: Moving Beyond ESG to Impact Investing, published by Columbia University Press, with a foreword by Larry Fink.


Now, considering that I had just spent a good part of the afternoon defending ESG against Terry, I found the title rather amusing. Moving Beyond ESG to Impact Investing.


Well, Terry, I have spent more than 30 years promoting Impact Investing myself.

So perhaps we are not quite as far apart as our debate suggested!

I suspect he is hoping that, after reading his book, I will finally come around to his way of thinking.

And who knows? I might even agree with him on a few more things.

Although, knowing myself, I will probably find something else to argue about!

But what I appreciated most was the warmth, humour and mutual respect behind our disagreement.


After all, the purpose of a good debate should not be to turn friends into opponents, but perhaps to turn opponents into friends.


And in a world where disagreements so often turn into hostility, I think that is something worth celebrating.

What I took away from London

We live in a world increasingly divided into opposing camps.

For or against ESG. For or against capitalism. For or against regulation.

We have become rather good at defending our positions and rather poor at listening to each other.

And perhaps even worse, we have started treating people who disagree with us as enemies rather than as people who may simply see the world differently.

But the world is far too complicated for such simple divisions.

A debate should not merely be about defeating your opponents.

Sometimes the real achievement is discovering that your disagreements reveal a better way forward.

That is what I enjoyed most about this exchange with Terry, Simon, Mike and Max.

And I left London with an even stronger conviction about something I have believed for many years.


The ultimate purpose of finance is not merely to create wealth. It is to help create a world worth living in.


A world where our children can breathe clean air, where businesses prosper without destroying communities, and where economic success does not come at the expense of human dignity.

Whether we call the framework ESG, Impact Investing or something entirely different is ultimately less important than what we actually achieve.

We should challenge greenwashing, demand genuine impact, protect smaller businesses from unnecessary burdens and ensure that sustainability standards serve society rather than narrow political or commercial interests.


The answer to a flawed system is not to abandon responsibility. It is to make responsibility measurable, transparent, proportionate and accountable.


So, my warm thanks to Terry and Simon for challenging my arguments, to Mike for standing alongside me, to Max and the CC Forum team for bringing us together, and especially to the wonderful audience for their engagement, laughter and thoughtful reactions.

And one final word to my dear friends Terry and Simon.

Next time we meet, perhaps we can agree on one thing before the debate even begins.


Let's repair the car together.


After all, I suspect we all want to reach more or less the same destination.

We just happen to disagree about who should be driving.

And considering our combined years of experience, perhaps we should let the next generation take the wheel!

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page